WHO BETTER? NFL

NFL · 2025 season

Baker Mayfield vs Geno Smith: who's better?

Baker Mayfield
2025 · QB · TB
VS
Geno Smith
2025 · QB · LV
Baker Mayfield takes it 6–3. Scored on per-game rates, so games missed don't decide it.
2025 season, side by side — scored per game
Baker MayfieldStatGeno Smith
217.2PASS YDS / G201.7
1.53PASS TDs / G1.27
63.2COMP %67.4
90.6QBR84.7
6.9YDS / CARRY2.7
0.06RUSH TDs / G0.00
1.00REC YDS / G0.73
0.06REC / G0.13
0.12TACKLES / G0.33
Context — shown, not scored
382RUSH YDS109
17GP15
Open the full comparison →

Pick the season, weight the stats that matter to you, and vote on who wins.

More NFL matchups