WHO BETTER? MLB

MLB · Career comparison

Luis Garcia Jr. vs Manny Machado: who's better?

Luis Garcia Jr.
Luis Garcia Jr.
1B · WSH
VS
Manny Machado
Manny Machado
3B · SD
Manny Machado takes it 7–1. Every category below is scored on career per-game rates, so a longer career doesn't win on volume alone.
Career comparison — per-game rates carry the verdict, totals shown for context
Luis Garcia Jr.StatManny Machado
.268AVG.275
0.11HR / G0.20
0.49RBI / G0.60
.732OPS.818
.301OBP.335
.431SLG.483
0.07SB / G0.06
0.44R / G0.57
Context — shown, not scored
708GP2003
Open the full comparison →

Pick the season, weight the stats that matter to you, and vote on who wins.

More MLB matchups